Sample shortlist · candidates written by us, real screener output
Virtual Assistant
This is what the screening delivers: every candidate scored against the brief, with screening notes, their answers and a graded work sample. These sample candidates were written by us and run through the real screener — the scores and notes are its unedited output.
At a glance
Highest score first. Scores within 2 points are level: when we had the screener read the same two applications again, the gap between them moved by up to 2. A must-have in the brief (below the list) costs 5 points when the application does not show it and 2 when it only partly does.
- Agustina R.Goes on to the interviewLevel with Kimberly A. (87 vs 86 is too close to call), with no part more than 2 points apart.87/100
- Kimberly A.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Hazel D. mainly on the work sample (87 vs 72).86/100
- Hazel D.Stops here68/100
2 of 3 clear 70, the score an applicant needs to go on to the written interview. A real shortlist only holds people who clear it and then the interview; the one below it is shown so you can see what the screener turns down.
The brief they were screened against
Role: Virtual Assistant · Band: $700–1,150/mo
Must-haves: inbox and calendar support for a US small-business owner, decides the routine without being chased, clean professional written English, a daily summary the owner can read in a minute
Nice to have: invoice chasing and light bookkeeping, Shopify order admin, Google Workspace and Slack
Scored on 2026-09-23 by the AI screener that grades real applicants: the virtual-assistant rubric, run on claude-sonnet-4-6. Nothing below was edited afterwards — including where it went against a candidate. The rubric and weights are published.
Agustina R. · 1 of 3
SCREEN 87/100How the 87 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%88
Five items, each with a number or named outcome, one clear ask, and a subject line that signals the ask — usable as-is.
- Scenario judgment 25%87
Triage logic is explicit: acknowledge first, then sequence by deadline, with a clear routine-vs-owner line on the invoice.
- Experience specificity 20%84
Four years, named company type, 35 cleaners, 60 sites, AR days cut from 41 to 27 with a specific method described.
- Written & spoken English 15%86
Phrases like 'nobody waits in silence' and 'answer the angry email first' are precise, confident, and correctly registered throughout.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,150 a month, inside the $700–1,150 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- inbox and calendar support for a US small-business owner — shown
I run the owner's inbox and calendar
- decides the routine without being chased — shown
I decide this myself
- clean professional written English — shown
nobody waits in silence
- a daily summary the owner can read in a minute — shown
Tue 13 Oct, end of day — one yes/no for you (item 5)
The parts, weighted as above, come to 87.
Screening notes
Strongest: AR improvement (41→27 days) and the work sample's five-item format with a single, binary owner ask show real operational discipline.
Concern: Ask sits at the very top of the band, leaving no negotiating room; Slack is self-described as newer.
Worth asking: What does the current owner's inbox volume look like daily, and how do they handle email triage priority rules?
Verdict: A well-evidenced, operationally sharp candidate whose written English and judgment both hold up under scrutiny.
Experience
7 years in admin and operations. The last 4 as the remote assistant to the owner of a Miami commercial cleaning company (35 cleaners, about 60 client sites): I run the owner's inbox and calendar, crew schedule changes, and accounts receivable. I brought average days to collect from 41 to 27 by invoicing the day a job closes and phoning, in English or Spanish, on day 10. Before that I spent 3 years as front-office supervisor at a Buenos Aires hotel, which is where I learned to answer the angry email first.
Tools
Google Workspace, Slack, QuickBooks Online (invoicing, AR reminders, bill entry), Bill.com, Jobber for crew scheduling, Calendly, Zapier (simple two-step automations), Notion, Canva (basic; design isn't my strength)
Scenario answer
Asked: Your employer is in back-to-back meetings all day and unreachable. Three things arrive at the same time: a client asks to reschedule tomorrow's 9am call, an unpaid supplier invoice is due today and the vendor has sent a follow-up, and a team member posted a Slack question yesterday that nobody answered. Walk through, in order, how you handle all three — what you decide yourself versus what waits for your employer.
First minute: nobody waits in silence. I send three short replies before I solve anything. To the client: 'Of course. I'll send you two new times within the hour.' To the vendor: 'Thanks for the reminder. I'm checking invoice 4471 now and will come back to you today.' In the Slack thread: 'Sorry this sat since yesterday. I'm on it and will answer by noon.' Then I solve them by deadline. 1. The invoice, due today. The owner approves the week's bills every Monday in Bill.com. If this one is on the approved list, releasing it is routine, so I do it now and send the vendor the payment date. If it isn't on the list, it isn't routine, however small. I check it against the PO and our last payment to this vendor (same amount range, same bank details; a change in bank details means a phone call to the number we already have), then tell the vendor it's with the owner today and they'll have a date tomorrow morning. It becomes the one question in my end-of-day summary. 2. The reschedule, for tomorrow 9am. I decide this myself. I look at the owner's week, offer two slots that fit the rules we agreed (no calls before 9:30 on Mondays, Friday afternoons kept free for site visits), and when the client picks, I move the invite and keep the same meeting link. If it's a client the owner is negotiating with, I still move it, but I mention it in the summary so the owner isn't surprised. 3. The Slack question, for the full answer. If it's about something written down, like a site's cleaning checklist or a supply order, I answer it and link the source. If it's the owner's call, I say exactly that and when they'll get an answer, which is better than a second day of silence. Honest note: our crews use WhatsApp, so Slack is newer for me. I've learned to check the Threads view at the start and end of every day, because that's where a question like this one hides.
Work sample
Asked: Pick any small business you've worked for or know well. Write the 5-item end-of-day summary you'd send the owner: what happened, what you decided yourself, and the one thing you need from them.
Subject: Tue 13 Oct, end of day — one yes/no for you (item 5) 1. New client: the Coral Gables dental office signed. Evening cleaning starts Monday 19 Oct with Luis's crew. It's in Jobber and on the invoice schedule. 2. Complaint handled: the Brickell office client said the 12th-floor restrooms were missed Monday night. The crew lead confirmed it, they re-cleaned at 7am, and I sent the property manager photos. No credit given; it's their first complaint this year. 3. Payments: $18,450 came in today from four clients. Overdue past 30 days is now $6,200, across two clients. Both promised payment this week; I'll call Friday if it hasn't arrived. 4. Supplies: I placed the monthly restock with the usual supplier, $1,340, within $60 of September's order. Arrives Thursday. 5. For you: the Doral condo building wants to go from weekly to twice-weekly service. They pay $1,300 a month now. Last time you quoted twice-weekly at 1.8 times the weekly price, which would be $2,340 a month. OK to send that? Yes or no is enough.
Availability
Full-time, 10am–7pm Buenos Aires time, which is 9am–6pm US Eastern from March to November and 8am–5pm in winter. No night shift. Three weeks' notice.
Kimberly A. · 2 of 3
SCREEN 86/100How the 86 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%87
Five-item summary is client-ready: concrete numbers, clear done/decided/need structure, and a specific ask with a deadline.
- Scenario judgment 25%85
Fraud-check on bank details, pre-approved limit logic, and tiered urgency ordering show sharp, evidenced judgment.
- Experience specificity 20%84
Specific numbers throughout: 120 emails/day, $14,200 to under $3,000 overdue, $2,000 approval limit, named tools.
- Written & spoken English 15%86
Prose is clean, professional, and varied; phrases like decides it in ten seconds show confident, natural register.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,000 a month, inside the $700–1,150 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- inbox and calendar support for a US small-business owner — shown
I run the inbox (around 120 emails a day, of which the owner sees about 10), a calendar of 20–25 meetings a week
- decides the routine without being chased — shown
address changes, cancellations and refunds under $75 on my own call
- clean professional written English — shown
A 'please pay, and note our new bank details' follow-up is the classic fraud, so any change means I call the vendor on the number we already have, not the one in the email
- a daily summary the owner can read in a minute — shown
Subject: EOD Wed 7 Oct (1 thing needs you)
The parts, weighted as above, come to 86.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario fraud-check and work sample daily summary are both immediately usable, with real numbers and clear owner/VA split.
Concern: No gap or weakness is visible in the application; depth of bookkeeping beyond QuickBooks invoice entry is unconfirmed.
Worth asking: What does reconciliation handoff to an accountant look like, and has the candidate managed a VA team or only solo?
Verdict: A well-evidenced, highly capable candidate whose ask sits comfortably inside the band and whose work product is close to client-ready.
Experience
4 years as the only VA to the owner of a US home-fragrance brand on Shopify, about $900K a year with 6 staff. I run the inbox (around 120 emails a day, of which the owner sees about 10), a calendar of 20–25 meetings a week, and order admin: address changes, cancellations and refunds under $75 on my own call. I also took over invoice chasing: wholesale accounts more than 30 days overdue went from $14,200 to under $3,000 in five months, mostly because the reminder now goes out on day 31 instead of whenever someone remembers.
Tools
Google Workspace (Gmail filters and labels, Calendar, Drive), Slack, Shopify admin, Gorgias, QuickBooks Online (invoices, bill entry and payment reminders — not reconciliations), Calendly, Notion, Loom, 1Password
Scenario answer
Asked: Your employer is in back-to-back meetings all day and unreachable. Three things arrive at the same time: a client asks to reschedule tomorrow's 9am call, an unpaid supplier invoice is due today and the vendor has sent a follow-up, and a team member posted a Slack question yesterday that nobody answered. Walk through, in order, how you handle all three — what you decide yourself versus what waits for your employer.
My rule: anything that only needs information I already have, I decide. Anything that spends money beyond what's pre-approved, or changes a relationship, I get ready so the owner can decide it in ten seconds later. In order: 1. The supplier invoice, because it's the only one whose deadline is today. Before paying anything I check three things. Does it match the purchase order or the last few bills from this vendor? Are the bank details the same ones we've paid before? A 'please pay, and note our new bank details' follow-up is the classic fraud, so any change means I call the vendor on the number we already have, not the one in the email. And is it inside my limit? With my current owner that's $2,000 for existing suppliers. If all three pass, I pay it today the way we paid their last invoice, send the vendor the remittance, and it goes in my summary. If it's over the limit, I don't pay. I tell the vendor it's with the owner for approval and they'll have a payment date tomorrow morning, and I ask whether a late fee applies, so the owner decides with the real cost in front of them. 2. The client reschedule, because the client should hear back within the hour and tomorrow's good slots fill up. This doesn't need the owner. I pick two times the owner would take, for example 11:30 tomorrow or 10:00 Thursday, never over the Friday team meeting, and offer both. When the client picks, I move the event, keep the same Zoom link, and add a line to the invite so the owner sees why it moved. 3. The Slack question. It has already waited a day, so it gets answered today, not added to tomorrow. If the answer exists somewhere I can check (a shipping cut-off, where a file lives, what we told a customer last time), I answer it and link the source. If it's a decision, like a discount for a wholesale account, a day off or a policy change, I tell the team member it will be in front of the owner tonight and when they'll hear back. All three go in the end-of-day summary, split into what I did and the one thing I need from the owner.
Work sample
Asked: Pick any small business you've worked for or know well. Write the 5-item end-of-day summary you'd send the owner: what happened, what you decided yourself, and the one thing you need from them.
Subject: EOD Wed 7 Oct (1 thing needs you) 1. DONE: Moved Rachel (Northside Gifts, wholesale) from Thu 9:00 to Thu 11:30, as requested. Same Zoom link; the reason is in the invite. 2. DECIDED: Paid the jar supplier's invoice #20417, $1,684.00, due today. Matches PO 311, same bank details as August, under your $2,000 limit. Remittance sent. 3. DECIDED: Answered Tessa's Slack question from Tuesday: the last day for holiday wholesale orders is Fri Nov 13, per the calendar we set in September. Pinned in #ops so it doesn't come up again. 4. FYI: 46 orders shipped, 3 address changes, 1 refund ($38.00, cracked jar, photo on file). Wholesale overdue is $2,870, all under 45 days; reminders went out this morning. 5. NEED FROM YOU: Northside Gifts asked for net 60 instead of net 30 on their $4,200 reorder. I told Rachel we'd confirm by Friday. A yes or no is enough. Nothing else is waiting on you.
Availability
Full-time, 9pm–6am PHT (9am–6pm ET). Two weeks' notice.
Hazel D. · 3 of 3
SCREEN 68/100How the 68 adds up · Competent but generic
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%72
Clean, scannable five-item summary with a clear decision/action/ask structure; slightly generic inbox line lacks specifics.
- Scenario judgment 25%66
Correct triage order and appropriate payment caution, but no concrete decision made on any item — all three are deferred or held.
- Experience specificity 20%58
Two US clients and three real tools named, but no numbers, volumes, or decisions made independently are described.
- Written & spoken English 15%78
Consistently correct grammar and professional register; phrase "I believe good communication is very important" is the only filler.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $750 a month, inside the $700–1,150 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 3 of 4 shown, 1 partly
- inbox and calendar support for a US small-business owner — shown
I manage their emails, schedule appointments in Google Calendar
- decides the routine without being chased — partly shown (−2)
I would reply to the client right away
- clean professional written English — shown
Here is my summary for today
- a daily summary the owner can read in a minute — shown
Here is my summary for today
The parts, weighted as above, come to 70; must-haves not fully shown cost 2, so 68.
Screening notes
Strongest: Work sample and English — the daily summary is clean, correctly structured, and immediately usable.
Concern: Scenario shows no independent decisions; every item is held or forwarded, suggesting limited autonomous judgment.
Worth asking: What routine tasks do they resolve without client input, and what does a typical week's inbox triage look like?
Verdict: A reliable, well-written candidate with solid core VA skills but thin evidence of proactive, unsupervised decision-making.
Experience
2 years as a general virtual assistant for two US clients, a real estate agent and a life coach. I manage their emails, schedule appointments in Google Calendar, do data entry, post on their social media and prepare simple reports. Before that I worked for 1 year as a customer service representative at a call centre in Davao. I am organised, reliable and a fast learner, and my clients say my communication is very clear.
Tools
Google Workspace, Calendly, Canva, Trello, Slack, Zoom, Microsoft Office
Scenario answer
Asked: Your employer is in back-to-back meetings all day and unreachable. Three things arrive at the same time: a client asks to reschedule tomorrow's 9am call, an unpaid supplier invoice is due today and the vendor has sent a follow-up, and a team member posted a Slack question yesterday that nobody answered. Walk through, in order, how you handle all three — what you decide yourself versus what waits for your employer.
Since my employer is in meetings all day, I would handle each item carefully and make sure nothing is missed. First, the client who wants to reschedule. I would reply to the client right away to let them know I received their request, that my employer is in meetings today, and that I will confirm a new time as soon as possible. I would check the calendar for open slots so I can suggest them to my employer. Second, the supplier invoice. I would reply to the vendor to thank them for the reminder and let them know the invoice has been forwarded for approval. I would also check that the amount is the same as their previous invoices. Since it involves payment, I would wait for my employer to approve it before anything is paid, because I do not want to make a mistake with money. Third, the Slack question. I would reply to the team member and let them know I will check with our employer and get back to them. At the end of the day I would send my employer a message listing all three items so they can decide quickly when their meetings are finished. I believe good communication is very important so that everyone knows what is happening.
Work sample
Asked: Pick any small business you've worked for or know well. Write the 5-item end-of-day summary you'd send the owner: what happened, what you decided yourself, and the one thing you need from them.
Hi [Owner], Here is my summary for today: 1. I replied to the new emails in the inbox and flagged the important ones for you to read. 2. I scheduled two showings for tomorrow afternoon and updated your Google Calendar. 3. I posted the new listing on Facebook and Instagram using the photographer's photos. 4. I followed up with the lender about the Johnson file, but they have not replied yet. I will follow up again tomorrow morning. 5. I need your approval on the photographer's invoice so I can send the payment. Please let me know if you have any questions or if there is anything else you need me to do. Thank you!
Availability
Full-time, 9pm–6am PHT (US Eastern business hours). Available immediately.
This is the artifact every search delivers
Post the role and the same screener runs on your real applicants — the questions arrive already written, and you read every finalist in full before any fee is due.
The same screener, other roles
- Customer Support VA
- Executive Assistant
- Bookkeeper
- Operations Manager
- Social Media Manager
- Data Entry Specialist
- Content Marketer
- Junior Developer
- Graphic Designer
- Sales Development Rep
- Real Estate VA
- E-commerce VA
- Bookkeeping Assistant
- Video Editor
- Copywriter
- SEO Specialist
- PPC Specialist
- WordPress Developer
- Shopify Developer
- Accountant
- Project Manager
- Lead Generation Specialist
- Web Designer