Sample shortlist · candidates written by us, real screener output
Accountant
This is what the screening delivers: every candidate scored against the brief, with screening notes, their answers and a graded work sample. These sample candidates were written by us and run through the real screener — the scores and notes are its unedited output.
At a glance
Highest score first. Scores within 2 points are level: when we had the screener read the same two applications again, the gap between them moved by up to 2. A must-have in the brief (below the list) costs 5 points when the application does not show it and 2 when it only partly does.
- Patricia V.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Lerato M. mainly on the brief: Lerato M. did not fully show 2 must-haves.89/100
- Lerato M.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Fernanda R. mainly on the work sample (88 vs 58).83/100
- Fernanda R.Stops here50/100
2 of 3 clear 70, the score an applicant needs to go on to the written interview. A real shortlist only holds people who clear it and then the interview; the one below it is shown so you can see what the screener turns down.
The brief they were screened against
Role: Accountant · Band: $1,000–1,700/mo
Must-haves: month-end close and management accounts for a small business, explains why margin moved rather than restating it, accruals and prepayments, a CPA-ready year-end pack
Nice to have: cash-flow forecasting, QuickBooks Online or Xero, inventory or e-commerce businesses, US GAAP familiarity
Scored on 2026-09-23 by the AI screener that grades real applicants: the accountant rubric, run on claude-sonnet-4-6. Nothing below was edited afterwards — including where it went against a candidate. The rubric and weights are published.
Patricia V. · 1 of 3
SCREEN 89/100How the 89 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%91
Splits the $6,300 gap into three named causes with dollars and margin points each, forecasts November, and ends with a specific decision and deadline.
- Scenario judgment 25%88
Sequences checks (timing before real cost), names the three-payday trap, job-level drill-down, and commits to a dollar-split by 9am before guessing.
- Experience specificity 20%87
Eight named clients, specific industries, accrual rebuild cutting CPA review from 11 to 4 hours, and a precise tool stack with use cases.
- Written & spoken English 15%86
Phrase 'The first guess is the one the owner remembers' shows register and precision; no errors; consistently direct and client-ready throughout.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,600 a month, inside the $1,000–1,700 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- month-end close and management accounts for a small business — shown
I own the close for eight clients
- explains why margin moved rather than restating it — shown
The seven points come from three places
- accruals and prepayments — shown
I rebuilt the prepaid and accrual schedules on books that had been cash-basis in all but name
- a CPA-ready year-end pack — shown
build their year-end packs for the 1120-S and 1065 returns
The parts, weighted as above, come to 89.
Screening notes
Strongest: Work sample is exceptional — causes quantified in dollars and points, a forward margin estimate, and a specific decision request with a deadline.
Concern: Self-described as slower on product/inventory businesses; limited exposure beyond service-sector clients.
Worth asking: How they handle a client who pushes back on a price-book increase, and whether they have direct client communication experience or work only through the CPA firm.
Verdict: A highly specific, well-evidenced candidate whose close and commentary work is at the top of what this role requires, asking near the top of the band.
Experience
9 years. Licensed CPA in the Philippines: 3 years in audit at a Manila firm, then 6 years at an outsourcing company that runs the monthly close for small-business clients of US CPA firms. I own the close for eight clients (two HVAC and plumbing companies, a physiotherapy group, a staffing agency and four marketing agencies) and build their year-end packs for the 1120-S and 1065 returns. At the staffing client I rebuilt the prepaid and accrual schedules on books that had been cash-basis in all but name, and the CPA firm's review time on that file went from about 11 hours to 4.
Tools
QuickBooks Online (Plus and Advanced — classes, projects, job costing), Xero, Excel (SUMIFS, XLOOKUP, Power Query), Karbon for close checklists, Gusto and ADP payroll reports for wage accruals, Bill.com, Dext
Scenario answer
Asked: You are preparing the month-end management accounts when you notice gross margin is 5 percentage points lower than last month, even though revenue was flat. The client calls and asks what happened. Walk through your exact process for investigating the variance — which accounts and line items you'd examine, in what order — and what you'd put in the commentary.
My clients are service businesses, so I'll answer the way I'd work one of those. My inventory experience is one client with a small parts stock, and I'd be slower on a product business. On the call I say what I know and when they'll have the rest: revenue held, the drop is in cost of sales, and I'll send the cause in dollars by 9am tomorrow. I don't guess a reason on the phone. The first guess is the one the owner remembers. The investigation, in order: 1. Rule out timing before looking for a real cost. Three checks. Was it a three-payday month? With biweekly payroll, two months a year have three paydays, and if wages are booked when paid instead of accrued by days worked, direct labour jumps by half for no real reason. Were supplier bills for last month's jobs posted this month? And did any accrual reverse without the real invoice arriving? 2. Direct labour, split into regular hours, overtime and subcontractors. Revenue can hold while the cost of delivering it moves: two technicians out means the same jobs get done by subcontractors at a higher rate. 3. Materials against what we charged. If the supplier's prices went up and our price book didn't, margin leaks on every job. 4. Job-level margin. I run project profitability for the month and read the five worst jobs. Callbacks, jobs quoted too low and warranty work usually sit there. 5. Revenue quality, even though the total held: discounts, credit notes, and jobs billed this month for work done last month. For the commentary, I split the drop into timing and real cost first, then real cost by cause, with dollars and points for each, which ones repeat, and what we're doing about them. If a timing error is mine, I post the correction before the commentary goes out rather than explaining it in a footnote. The owner reads the margin line, not the footnote.
Work sample
Asked: Write the 3-paragraph management commentary you'd send a business owner for a month where revenue was $90,000, gross margin was 36% (down from 43% the prior month), and net profit was $3,600. Explain the margin movement — don't just report it.
OCTOBER MANAGEMENT COMMENTARY Revenue was $90,000, the same as September, but gross margin dropped from 43% to 36%. Gross profit was $32,400 against the $38,700 we'd have made at September's margin: $6,300 less. Overheads were steady at $28,800, so net profit was $3,600; without the margin drop it would have been $9,900. I checked first whether this was a timing effect, and it isn't. October had three biweekly paydays, but wages are accrued by days worked, and the $1,150 of parts delivered in October but invoiced on 3 November is accrued into October, so both months are on the same basis. The seven points come from three places. Subcontractors: with two technicians out for most of the month, six installs went to outside crews, costing $3,600 more than our own technicians would have (4.0 points). Parts: the supply house raised prices on water heaters and copper fittings from 1 October, but our flat-rate price book still uses the old costs, so we absorbed $1,800 (2.0 points). Callbacks: two unbilled warranty visits, against none in September, cost $900 in labour and parts (1.0 point). Both were on installs by the same technician, which I've passed to the service manager. For November, the subcontractor cost ends when both technicians are back next week, and the two callbacks were one-offs, so margin should recover to about 41% even with the price book unchanged: about $8,100 of net profit on the same revenue and overheads. The remaining 2 points are the price book. The 14 flat-rate tasks that use those parts bill about $22,500 a month, so raising them by 8% recovers the $1,800 at October's volumes. That's the one decision I need from you, ideally by Friday, when the new price book goes out to the technicians' tablets.
Availability
Full-time, 9pm–6am PHT (9am–6pm ET during US daylight saving; I start an hour later in winter). 30 days' notice.
Lerato M. · 2 of 3
SCREEN 83/100How the 83 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%88
Commentary leads with dollar impact ($6,300 lost gross profit), isolates three causes to the point, quantifies each in dollars and percentage points, separates one-off from recurring, flags the 3PL damage claim, and closes with a specific decision and deadline.
- Scenario judgment 25%87
Structures investigation cheapest-check-first, separates timing errors from real cost shifts, splits by channel and discount code, and commits to a day-3 margin check to own the next call.
- Experience specificity 20%85
CA(SA) qualification, four years sole management accountant for a named $1.2M Shopify/wholesale brand, day-6 close, freight-reclassification find with a 4-point margin impact and a 6% reprice outcome.
- Written & spoken English 15%84
Phrase 'three points explained, two under review' shows precise, confident register; prose throughout is clean, direct, and calibrated for a US business owner.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,450 a month, inside the $1,000–1,700 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 2 of 4 shown, 2 partly
- month-end close and management accounts for a small business — shown
four years as the only management accountant for a US-owned tea and coffee brand
- explains why margin moved rather than restating it — shown
Three things in cost of sales explain all seven points
- accruals and prepayments — partly shown (−2)
last month's accruals reversed with no invoice behind them
- a CPA-ready year-end pack — partly shown (−2)
leave tax questions to the owner's CPA
The parts, weighted as above, come to 87; must-haves not fully shown cost 4, so 83.
Screening notes
Strongest: Work sample and scenario both show a candidate who leads with dollars, separates one-off from recurring, and drives a decision — not just a reporter of numbers.
Concern: Accruals and prepayments appear only in the scenario investigation checklist, not as a described routine; a CPA-ready year-end pack is never described as a task they have built.
Worth asking: Can they walk through what their year-end pack contained and how they prepared it for the CPA?
Verdict: A well-evidenced, commercially sharp management accountant whose ask sits comfortably inside the band, with two must-haves needing a follow-up question to confirm.
Experience
7 years: a three-year training contract at a Johannesburg audit firm, where I qualified as a CA(SA), then four years as the only management accountant for a US-owned tea and coffee brand doing about $1.2M a year on Shopify and wholesale to around 40 grocery stores. I closed by working day 6 and wrote the commentary the owner actually read. My most useful find was inbound freight booked as an overhead instead of into stock cost, which made gross margin look about 4 points better than it was and hid that wholesale barely broke even; we repriced wholesale by 6% the next quarter. My training was IFRS; I've kept US GAAP books for four years and leave tax questions to the owner's CPA.
Tools
Xero (daily for four years), QuickBooks Online (less depth than Xero), A2X for Shopify payouts, Cin7 for stock and landed cost, Fathom for the monthly pack, Float for 13-week cash-flow forecasts, Excel (SUMIFS, pivot tables, Power Query), Dext
Scenario answer
Asked: You are preparing the month-end management accounts when you notice gross margin is 5 percentage points lower than last month, even though revenue was flat. The client calls and asks what happened. Walk through your exact process for investigating the variance — which accounts and line items you'd examine, in what order — and what you'd put in the commentary.
First, the call. The client got to this before my commentary did, so I don't say 'let me look into it'. I tell them what I already know (sales held, and cost of sales took five more cents of every dollar) and that they'll have the cause, in dollars, by 3pm their time. Then the investigation, cheapest check first: 1. Is last month the odd one? In my experience a five-point swing on flat sales is as often a timing error as a real cost. I check cut-off both ways: supplier bills dated last month but posted this month, last month's accruals reversed with no invoice behind them, and whether the stock count was taken on a different day of the month. 2. Cost of sales line by line, as a percentage of sales, for both months: product cost, inbound freight and duty, packaging, fulfilment, merchant fees, stock adjustments. A write-off or count adjustment lands all at once, so I read that line first. 3. Unit cost on the ten products that make up most of sales. I compare this month's landed cost per unit with the last three purchases. That's where a supplier price rise or an expensive shipment shows up. 4. Mix and discounts, even though revenue was flat. Flat revenue can hide more wholesale at a lower margin, or more units sold on a discount code. I split sales and gross margin by channel and by discount code. 5. Only then the smaller stuff: returns, damaged stock, freight credits that never arrived. The commentary leads with the money, not the percentage: what the drop cost in gross profit, how much of it is one-off and how much will repeat, and the decision the owner has to make, if there is one. If I can only explain part of it, I say which part is still open and when I'll close it. I'd rather send 'three points explained, two under review' than a tidy story that's wrong next month. And one change after this: a margin check on day 3 of the close, so next time the owner hears it from me first.
Work sample
Asked: Write the 3-paragraph management commentary you'd send a business owner for a month where revenue was $90,000, gross margin was 36% (down from 43% the prior month), and net profit was $3,600. Explain the margin movement — don't just report it.
SEPTEMBER MANAGEMENT COMMENTARY Sales were $90,000, level with August, but gross margin fell from 43% to 36%. On the same sales that is $6,300 less gross profit ($32,400 instead of $38,700), and it is the whole reason net profit came in at $3,600 rather than $9,900. Overheads were $28,800, in line with plan, so nothing below gross profit needs your attention this month. Three things in cost of sales explain all seven points. First, air freight on the late restock of our two best-selling blends, which sold through within the month: $2,700 more than sea freight would have cost (3.0 points). We chose it to avoid a three-week stockout, and it won't repeat unless the next shipment is late too. Second, the main supplier's new price list from 1 September: unit costs on our five best-sellers rose about 8%, adding $2,250 (2.5 points). This one repeats every month. Third, the quarter-end stock count found $1,350 of damaged stock, written off to cost of sales (1.5 points). That is more than the last three counts combined, so before I accept it I've asked the 3PL for their damage log. If it happened in their warehouse, it's a claim against them, not our cost. For October, if sales hold at $90,000, gross margin should come back to about 40.5%: the supplier increase stays, the freight and the write-off don't. On current overheads that is a net profit of about $7,650. The decision I need from you is whether to pass the supplier increase on. Those five products bring in about $45,000 a month, so a 5% price rise on them covers the $2,250 if volumes hold. I'd like to settle it before the October price list goes to the wholesale accounts on the 10th.
Availability
Full-time, 1pm–10pm SAST, which is 7am–4pm US Eastern in summer and 6am–3pm in winter. One calendar month's notice.
Fernanda R. · 3 of 3
SCREEN 50/100How the 50 adds up · Thin
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%58
Restates the margin drop with arithmetic but never names a specific cause; commentary stays conditional throughout.
- Scenario judgment 25%55
Identifies cost-of-sales as the driver and checks classification errors, but investigation steps stay high-level and generic.
- Experience specificity 20%62
Six years and a named US client with QuickBooks Online are specific; no numbers, decisions, or named outcomes beyond that.
- Written & spoken English 15%72
Clear, correct, and professional throughout; phrasing like 'so they can make good decisions' is plain but appropriate for a US client.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,200 a month, inside the $1,000–1,700 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 1 of 4 shown, 1 partly
- month-end close and management accounts for a small business — shown
preparing monthly financial statements, bank reconciliations and tax declarations for small and medium businesses
- explains why margin moved rather than restating it — partly shown (−2)
The decrease in gross margin is because the cost of sales increased while revenue stayed the same. This can be due to higher prices from suppliers, higher freight costs or a change in the products sold. We are reviewing the supplier invoices to confirm the main causes.
- accruals and prepayments — not shown (−5)
- a CPA-ready year-end pack — not shown (−5)
The parts, weighted as above, come to 62; must-haves not fully shown cost 12, so 50.
Screening notes
Strongest: Six years of small-business accounting plus an active US client engagement in QuickBooks Online gives a credible foundation.
Concern: Accruals/prepayments and a CPA-ready year-end pack are never mentioned anywhere in the application.
Worth asking: Can they describe a specific accruals or year-end pack they have prepared, and what "currently studying US GAAP" means in practice?
Verdict: A competent, clear candidate with relevant small-business experience but two must-haves entirely absent and commentary that stays conditional rather than diagnostic.
Experience
6 years as an accountant at an accounting firm in Guadalajara, preparing monthly financial statements, bank reconciliations and tax declarations for small and medium businesses, mostly Mexican companies. For the last year and a half I have also worked for a US client, a small furniture importer, doing their monthly close in QuickBooks Online. I am a Contadora Pública with strong knowledge of accounting principles, and I am very responsible and organised with deadlines. I am currently studying US GAAP.
Tools
CONTPAQi, QuickBooks Online, Excel (pivot tables), SAT portal for Mexican tax filings, Google Sheets
Scenario answer
Asked: You are preparing the month-end management accounts when you notice gross margin is 5 percentage points lower than last month, even though revenue was flat. The client calls and asks what happened. Walk through your exact process for investigating the variance — which accounts and line items you'd examine, in what order — and what you'd put in the commentary.
When the gross margin is 5 points lower and the revenue is the same, it means the cost of sales increased. I would tell the client that I am reviewing the information and that I will send the explanation together with the management accounts. To investigate, I would first compare the income statement of this month with the previous month to see which accounts changed. Then I would review the cost of sales account in detail, looking at the purchases and the inventory movements, to find higher costs or unusual transactions. I would also check that all the sales were recorded correctly and that no expenses were classified in cost of sales by mistake, because an error in the classification can change the margin. If I find the reason, for example that a supplier increased prices, I would confirm it with the supplier invoices and include it in the commentary. In the commentary I would explain that the gross margin decreased because of the increase in the cost of sales, show the comparison with the previous month in a table, and recommend that the client review prices with suppliers or increase sale prices. I think it is important that the client understands the numbers so they can make good decisions.
Work sample
Asked: Write the 3-paragraph management commentary you'd send a business owner for a month where revenue was $90,000, gross margin was 36% (down from 43% the prior month), and net profit was $3,600. Explain the margin movement — don't just report it.
MANAGEMENT COMMENTARY Revenue for the month was $90,000, the same level as the previous month. Gross margin was 36%, compared with 43% in the previous month, a decrease of 7 percentage points. Gross profit was $32,400 and cost of sales was $57,600, which is 64% of revenue compared with 57% in the previous month. The decrease in gross margin is because the cost of sales increased while revenue stayed the same. This can be due to higher prices from suppliers, higher freight costs or a change in the products sold. We are reviewing the supplier invoices to confirm the main causes. Operating expenses were $28,800 and net profit was $3,600, which is 4% of revenue. We recommend reviewing the purchase prices with the main suppliers and analysing if it is necessary to adjust the sale prices to recover the margin in the next months. We will continue monitoring the cost of sales and inform you of any important changes.
Availability
Full-time, 8am–5pm Guadalajara time (Central Mexico), which overlaps with US business hours. Available in two weeks.
This is the artifact every search delivers
Post the role and the same screener runs on your real applicants — the questions arrive already written, and you read every finalist in full before any fee is due.
The same screener, other roles
- Customer Support VA
- Executive Assistant
- Bookkeeper
- Operations Manager
- Social Media Manager
- Data Entry Specialist
- Content Marketer
- Junior Developer
- Graphic Designer
- Sales Development Rep
- Real Estate VA
- E-commerce VA
- Bookkeeping Assistant
- Virtual Assistant
- Video Editor
- Copywriter
- SEO Specialist
- PPC Specialist
- WordPress Developer
- Shopify Developer
- Project Manager
- Lead Generation Specialist
- Web Designer