Sample shortlist · candidates written by us, real screener output
Bookkeeping Assistant
This is what the screening delivers: every candidate scored against the brief, with screening notes, their answers and a graded work sample. These sample candidates were written by us and run through the real screener — the scores and notes are its unedited output.
At a glance
Highest score first. Scores within 2 points are level: when we had the screener read the same two applications again, the gap between them moved by up to 2. A must-have in the brief (below the list) costs 5 points when the application does not show it and 2 when it only partly does.
- Joanna P.Goes on to the interviewLevel with Jasmine S. at 87, part for part.87/100
- Jasmine S.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Valeria G. mainly on the scenario answer (91 vs 38).87/100
- Valeria G.Stops here54/100
2 of 3 clear 70, the score an applicant needs to go on to the written interview. A real shortlist only holds people who clear it and then the interview; the one below it is shown so you can see what the screener turns down.
The brief they were screened against
Role: Bookkeeping Assistant · Band: $600–1,000/mo
Must-haves: high-volume transaction entry and categorisation in QuickBooks Online or Xero, receipt and invoice matching, asks rather than guesses on an ambiguous category, works cleanly under a senior bookkeeper's review
Nice to have: Dext or Hubdoc, bank-feed rules, AP invoice entry in Bill.com
Scored on 2026-09-23 by the AI screener that grades real applicants: the bookkeeping-assistant rubric, run on claude-sonnet-4-6. Nothing below was edited afterwards — including where it went against a candidate. The rubric and weights are published.
Joanna P. · 1 of 3
SCREEN 87/100How the 87 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%87
Eight transactions, correct splits, accrual prepaid logic, and a capitalisation-threshold check against the client's own file notes.
- Scenario judgment 25%91
Parks ambiguous entries in Ask My Accountant, finishes the 170, drafts a precise handoff message with dollar amounts and a rule caveat.
- Experience specificity 20%84
1,300–1,600 transactions monthly across nine named client types, error-rate trajectory, vendor-notes sheet, ProAdvisor cert, Dext and Bill.com named.
- Written & spoken English 15%82
Consistently clear, correct register throughout; phrase 'the amounts are in the period and the bank feed is cleared' is precise and professional.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $850 a month, inside the $600–1,000 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- high-volume transaction entry and categorisation in QuickBooks Online or Xero — shown
I enter and categorise 1,300–1,600 transactions a month across nine small businesses in QuickBooks Online
- receipt and invoice matching — shown
Dext Prepare (supplier rules, publishing to QuickBooks)
- asks rather than guesses on an ambiguous category — shown
For these I don't pick either category, even though last month's coding would probably be right. I post them to Ask My Accountant
- works cleanly under a senior bookkeeper's review — shown
two senior bookkeepers review everything before close
The parts, weighted as above, come to 87.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer — specific holding-account mechanic, dollar-level handoff message, and explicit rule-creation restraint show genuine judgment.
Concern: Xero depth is thin; one client, lower volume, reconciliations only.
Worth asking: What is the largest single-month transaction volume they have handled alone, without a second bookkeeper on the same client?
Verdict: A well-evidenced, methodical candidate whose scenario answer and work sample both reflect real bookkeeping discipline, with ask sitting comfortably inside the band.
Experience
3 years as a bookkeeping assistant at a Makati outsourcing firm that keeps the books for clients of US accounting practices. I enter and categorise 1,300–1,600 transactions a month across nine small businesses in QuickBooks Online — two restaurants, a dental practice, three trades companies and three online stores — and two senior bookkeepers review everything before close. In my first quarter they corrected about 1 entry in 25. By the end of my second year it was under 1 in 200, mostly because I started keeping a vendor-notes sheet per client listing every vendor that can land in more than one category.
Tools
QuickBooks Online (daily, ProAdvisor certified), Dext Prepare (supplier rules, publishing to QuickBooks), Bill.com for AP entry on two clients, Xero (bank reconciliations for one client — much less volume than QuickBooks), Excel and Google Sheets (VLOOKUP, SUMIFS, pivot tables), Slack
Scenario answer
Asked: Halfway through entering 200 expense receipts, you reach a batch of 30 where the category is genuinely ambiguous — the vendor name is the same supplier used for both 'professional services' and 'software subscriptions' depending on the invoice type. The bookkeeper who makes final categorisation calls is out for the day and the deadline to push these entries is 4pm. Walk through exactly what you do: which entries you complete, how you flag the ambiguous ones, and what you send the bookkeeper before you finish.
The 4pm deadline covers all 200 receipts, so my first decision is not to let 30 stuck ones hold up the 170 that aren't. 1. Park the 30, finish the other 70. I leave the 30 unpublished in Dext, note where I stopped, and enter the rest at normal speed with receipts attached. That leaves the afternoon for the hard ones. 2. Open all 30 source documents and sort them by what the paper proves. A vendor that sells both usually shows it on the invoice: a subscription invoice has a plan name, a seat count and a billing period; a services invoice has hours, a project name or a statement-of-work number. If 19 of the 30 are clear on the invoice, those are not guesses, so I enter them, each with a memo like 'Software per invoice: Pro plan, 12 seats, Oct 1–31' or 'Prof services per invoice: 6.5 hrs onboarding'. The bookkeeper can check my reason without reopening the PDF. 3. The other 11 are card receipts with only the vendor name and a total. For these I don't pick either category, even though last month's coding would probably be right. I post them to Ask My Accountant, the holding account our firm sets up in every client file, with both possible categories in the memo, so the amounts are in the period and the bank feed is cleared, and the only open question is the category. If the client has given us a login to the vendor's billing portal, I pull those invoices first and move as many as I can into step 2. 4. I don't create a bank rule for this vendor today, even though it would save time next month. A rule on the vendor name would push every future invoice into one category, which is the exact mistake I'm avoiding. 5. At 3:30 I check that the total entered matches the receipt list to the cent, that every entry has its image attached, and that Ask My Accountant holds exactly the 11. Then one message to the bookkeeper, on whichever channel they check first in the morning: '[Client]: all 200 receipts are in QuickBooks and the total ties to the receipt list. [Vendor]: 19 coded from the invoice lines, memo on each. 11 are card receipts with no invoice detail; they're in Ask My Accountant with both options noted. 9 of those 11 are exactly $249.00, the Pro plan price on the invoices I could read, so I'd suggest Software for those. The other 2 ($1,800 and $2,450) I can't call. I'll reclass as soon as you reply. For later: an amount-based rule for the $249 charge would be safe; a vendor rule wouldn't.'
Work sample
Asked: List 8 realistic expense transactions and the QuickBooks or Xero category you'd assign to each. For two where the category is genuinely debatable, explain your reasoning.
CLIENT: a 14-person landscaping company in Charlotte, NC. QuickBooks Online, accrual basis, categories from the client's own chart of accounts. 1. Oct 1, Jobber, $3,588.00 (annual plan, paid upfront) — Prepaid Expenses (see A) 2. Oct 3, Shell, $118.42 (fuel, crew truck 2) — Vehicle: Fuel 3. Oct 6, SiteOne Landscape Supply, $1,264.80 (mulch, pine straw and 40 boxwoods for the Harris Rd job) — Cost of Goods Sold: Job Materials 4. Oct 8, Google Ads, $600.00 — Advertising & Marketing 5. Oct 10, local small-engine repair shop, $412.50 (belts and blades on two mowers) — Repairs & Maintenance: Equipment 6. Oct 14, The Home Depot, $2,146.18 — split: $1,497.00 Small Tools & Equipment / $649.18 Cost of Goods Sold: Job Materials (see B) 7. Oct 20, NEXT Insurance, $386.00 (monthly general liability) — Insurance: General Liability 8. Oct 27, Verizon, $286.40 (four crew-lead phones) — Utilities: Phone A — THE ANNUAL JOBBER PLAN $3,588 paid on October 1 covers October to September. The books are on accrual, so I'd post it to Prepaid Expenses and release $299 a month to Software & Subscriptions; otherwise October carries a whole year of software and the next eleven months carry none. Why it's debatable: some firms expense annual prepayments under a set amount straight away, even on accrual, because the effect on any one month is small. I don't know this firm's threshold yet, so I'd post it to Prepaid, set up the $299 recurring journal as a reminder rather than scheduled so nothing posts on its own, and ask at the first review. B — THE HOME DEPOT RECEIPT One receipt, two different things: a backpack blower and a string trimmer ($1,497.00 together) and $649.18 of edging, landscape fabric and stakes for the Harris Rd job. The materials go to Job Materials so the job cost is right. The tools are the debatable part: they'll last several seasons, so you could argue they're fixed assets. Each one is well under the $2,500 per-item capitalisation policy in this client's file notes, so I'd expense them to Small Tools & Equipment and list both items in the memo. If the bookkeeper wants them on the fixed-asset register instead, the memo makes it a two-minute reclass.
Availability
Full-time, 9pm–6am PHT (9am–6pm ET). I move my shift an hour when US daylight saving ends, so it stays 9 to 6 Eastern. Two weeks' notice.
Jasmine S. · 2 of 3
SCREEN 87/100How the 87 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%87
Eight transactions, correct categories, two debatable ones argued with specific dollar thresholds, a split Amazon line, and a holding-account call on the personal item.
- Scenario judgment 25%91
Sequenced steps, duplicate-check logic, a hard 3:30 cutoff to holding, and a fully drafted handoff message with counts and dollar totals.
- Experience specificity 20%84
1,800 invoices a month, Bill.com AP, duplicate catch at $3,480, five more found that year — specific numbers and a self-initiated process change.
- Written & spoken English 15%82
Consistently clear and professional; the handoff message reads exactly right for a US client-facing context with no register slips.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $950 a month, inside the $600–1,000 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- high-volume transaction entry and categorisation in QuickBooks Online or Xero — shown
2 years on a four-client bookkeeping team in QuickBooks Online and Xero
- receipt and invoice matching — shown
each matched to a work order or purchase order before it went for approval
- asks rather than guesses on an ambiguous category — shown
What I won't do is code all 30 the way this vendor was coded last month
- works cleanly under a senior bookkeeper's review — shown
7 are in the holding account, with both options and my suggestion for each in the attached sheet
The parts, weighted as above, come to 87.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer — sequenced, time-stamped, with a fully drafted handoff message and explicit refusal to force-fit ambiguous entries.
Concern: QBO/Xero depth is entry-level only; no chart-of-accounts setup or year-end experience stated.
Worth asking: How they handle a senior bookkeeper who disagrees with a holding-account call they made.
Verdict: A disciplined, detail-oriented candidate whose AP volume, duplicate-detection initiative, and explicit ask-don't-guess method align closely with the role's core requirements.
Experience
5 years. 3 years in accounts payable at a Cebu shared-services centre for a US property-management company: about 1,800 vendor invoices a month through Bill.com, each matched to a work order or purchase order before it went for approval. Then 2 years on a four-client bookkeeping team in QuickBooks Online and Xero. In AP I caught a roofing contractor billing the same $3,480 repair twice under different invoice numbers, three weeks apart. After that I added a duplicate check on amount plus property, not just invoice number, and it found five more that year.
Tools
Bill.com (3 years — invoice entry, approval routing, vendor records), QuickBooks Online and Xero (2 years on entry and bank feeds; I have not set up a chart of accounts or done a year-end in either), Hubdoc, Dext Prepare, Excel (XLOOKUP, conditional formatting for duplicate checks), Google Sheets, Yardi (work orders, read-only)
Scenario answer
Asked: Halfway through entering 200 expense receipts, you reach a batch of 30 where the category is genuinely ambiguous — the vendor name is the same supplier used for both 'professional services' and 'software subscriptions' depending on the invoice type. The bookkeeper who makes final categorisation calls is out for the day and the deadline to push these entries is 4pm. Walk through exactly what you do: which entries you complete, how you flag the ambiguous ones, and what you send the bookkeeper before you finish.
This is the problem I dealt with every week in AP: one vendor, two kinds of invoice, and the vendor name tells you nothing. What I do, in order: 1. Set the 30 aside and finish the other 70 first. They aren't blocked, and the 4pm deadline is for them too. 2. Put the 30 in a quick sheet (date, amount, invoice number, the description line) and sort by invoice number. In my AP work, vendors that sold both usually billed them from different numbering series, or showed a plan and a billing period on one kind and hours on the other. Once they're side by side, most of them sort themselves. 3. While they're side by side, check for duplicates: same amount, same date, different invoice number. A batch of look-alike invoices from one vendor is exactly where a double-entered receipt hides. 4. For the ones still unclear, look at how the bookkeeper coded this vendor in earlier months at the same amount. I use that to write my suggestion, not to post. 5. If the firm lets us ask vendors for invoice copies (my current team does), email the vendor's billing contact before lunch for the missing ones. In my experience billing teams answer the same day, and the invoice ends the question for good. 6. Enter what the paper decides, with the reason in the memo. Anything still unclear at 3:30 goes to the holding account with both possible categories in the memo, so the totals are complete and nothing is coded on a guess. 7. At 3:45, check the count and the dollar total against the receipt log, and that every entry has its receipt attached. What I won't do is code all 30 the way this vendor was coded last month. That's right most of the time, and the time it's wrong is a $4,000 implementation invoice sitting in Software until the CPA asks why software doubled. Before 4pm I send the bookkeeper: '[Client] receipts: 199 of 200 entered, and the total ties to the receipt log less one $640 receipt I held back. It looks like a duplicate (same amount and date as another, different invoice number); details in the sheet. [Vendor]: 22 coded from the invoice lines, reason in each memo. 7 are in the holding account, with both options and my suggestion for each in the attached sheet. The 30th is that possible duplicate. I've asked the vendor for copies of 3 of the 7, and if they reply tonight I'll update before you log in.'
Work sample
Asked: List 8 realistic expense transactions and the QuickBooks or Xero category you'd assign to each. For two where the category is genuinely debatable, explain your reasoning.
CLIENT: a physical-therapy practice with two clinics in Tucson, AZ. QuickBooks Online; bills come in through Hubdoc, categories from the client's chart of accounts. 1. Nov 2, landlord for clinic 2, $6,850.00 (monthly rent) — Rent: Clinic 2 2. Nov 3, Medline, $1,128.40 (resistance bands, electrode pads, ultrasound gel; matched to the packing slip) — Medical Supplies 3. Nov 5, WebPT, $1,260.00 (monthly subscription, both clinics) — Software & Subscriptions 4. Nov 9, Tucson Electric Power, $612.35 — Utilities: Electric 5. Nov 10, commercial cleaning contractor, $950.00 (twice-weekly cleaning) — Janitorial 6. Nov 13, flooring contractor, $4,200.00 — Repairs & Maintenance, flagged (see A) 7. Nov 18, Amazon, $312.47 — split three ways (see B) 8. Nov 24, continuing-education provider, $495.00 (one therapist's certification course) — Education & Training A — THE $4,200 FLOORING INVOICE New flooring in two treatment rooms plus drywall patching. If it was water damage and they replaced like with like, it's a repair. If it was an upgrade or part of a remodel, it's closer to a leasehold improvement that gets depreciated. The invoice doesn't say which. I'd keep two questions apart: payment and category. The bill is due in 15 days and the clinic manager signed off the work, so I enter it and it gets paid on time. For the category I code it to Repairs & Maintenance, because that's what the invoice describes, and flag it, because it's over the $2,500 line where our firm asks before expensing. The flag carries the one question that settles it: was this water damage or a planned upgrade? B — THE AMAZON ORDER One order, three different things: foam rollers and bands ($188.50, Medical Supplies), a label printer for the front desk ($89.99, Office Supplies & Equipment), and a pair of kids' headphones ($33.98). I split the first two. The headphones might be for the waiting room, or they might be personal. That isn't mine to decide, so the $33.98 goes to the holding account with the question for the owner, through the bookkeeper.
Availability
Full-time, 8pm–5am PHT, which is 8am–5pm US Eastern during daylight saving. 30 days' notice to my current employer.
Valeria G. · 3 of 3
SCREEN 54/100How the 54 adds up · Thin
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%72
Eight transactions correctly categorised with real tool names; two debatable items reasoned through with amount-size and asset logic, though reasoning is brief.
- Scenario judgment 25%38
Candidate force-fits the ambiguous 30 using prior-month patterns rather than holding them for the bookkeeper, directly contradicting the role's core requirement.
- Experience specificity 20%62
Names QuickBooks Online, Siigo, a Bogotá firm, a US marketing agency, and 8 months of US-client work, but no transaction volumes or reconciliation specifics.
- Written & spoken English 15%74
Clear, correct, and professional throughout; phrasing like 'I am available tomorrow to make any changes' is natural and appropriately toned for a US client.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $800 a month, inside the $600–1,000 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 1 of 4 shown, 2 partly
- high-volume transaction entry and categorisation in QuickBooks Online or Xero — shown
entering their expenses and receipts in QuickBooks Online
- receipt and invoice matching — partly shown (−2)
entering their expenses and receipts in QuickBooks Online
- asks rather than guesses on an ambiguous category — not shown (−5)
- works cleanly under a senior bookkeeper's review — partly shown (−2)
I would send an email to the bookkeeper explaining that there were 30 receipts from this supplier where the category was not clear
The parts, weighted as above, come to 63; must-haves not fully shown cost 9, so 54.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer is well-structured and deadline-aware, and the work sample shows correct QBO category logic with brief but real reasoning.
Concern: On the core must-have — ask rather than guess — the candidate explicitly guesses, categorising the 30 ambiguous entries from prior months rather than holding them for the bookkeeper.
Worth asking: Has the candidate ever held entries unposted pending a senior review, and what is the highest weekly transaction volume they have processed?
Verdict: Competent QBO entry experience and clean English, but the scenario answer reveals a force-fit instinct that is the exact behaviour this role screens out.
Experience
2 years as an accounting assistant at an accounting firm in Bogotá, doing data entry, bank reconciliations and supplier invoices for local small businesses in Siigo. For the last 8 months I have also supported a US client, a small marketing agency, entering their expenses and receipts in QuickBooks Online. I have a degree in Contaduría Pública. I am very organised and detail-oriented, and I always try to keep the books up to date.
Tools
QuickBooks Online, Siigo, Excel, Google Sheets, Gmail
Scenario answer
Asked: Halfway through entering 200 expense receipts, you reach a batch of 30 where the category is genuinely ambiguous — the vendor name is the same supplier used for both 'professional services' and 'software subscriptions' depending on the invoice type. The bookkeeper who makes final categorisation calls is out for the day and the deadline to push these entries is 4pm. Walk through exactly what you do: which entries you complete, how you flag the ambiguous ones, and what you send the bookkeeper before you finish.
If I find 30 receipts where the category is not clear and the bookkeeper is not available, I would not stop working, because the deadline is 4pm and the other entries also need to be finished. First, I would finish entering all the receipts that are clear, so the other 170 entries are done on time. For the 30 ambiguous ones, I would look at how this supplier was categorised in previous months in QuickBooks and use the same category, because that is probably how the bookkeeper wants it. If the invoice description looks like consulting, I would put it in professional services, and if it looks like a software plan, in software subscriptions. I would add a note in the memo of these 30 entries saying 'please review category', so the bookkeeper can find them easily. Before 4pm I would check that all 200 entries are complete and that the totals are correct. Then I would send an email to the bookkeeper explaining that there were 30 receipts from this supplier where the category was not clear, that I categorised them based on the previous months, and that they are marked for review. I would also say that I am available tomorrow to make any changes. I think it is important to meet the deadline and also keep the bookkeeper informed.
Work sample
Asked: List 8 realistic expense transactions and the QuickBooks or Xero category you'd assign to each. For two where the category is genuinely debatable, explain your reasoning.
Examples from the small marketing agency I support, in QuickBooks Online: 1. Adobe, $89.99 — Software & Subscriptions 2. Office Depot, $64.30 — Office Supplies 3. Uber, $27.50 — Travel 4. Zoom, $21.99 — Software & Subscriptions 5. Upwork (freelance designer), $450.00 — Contractors 6. Comcast Business, $119.00 — Utilities 7. Amazon, $156.20 — Office Supplies 8. Restaurant, $86.50 — Meals Debatable 1: The Amazon purchase was a desk lamp and a keyboard. It could be Office Supplies or Office Equipment. I chose Office Supplies because the amount is small and it is not a big asset. Debatable 2: The restaurant receipt was a lunch with a client. It could be Meals or Entertainment. I chose Meals because it was a business lunch and not an event.
Availability
Full-time, 8am–5pm Colombia time, which is close to US Eastern hours. Available in two weeks.
This is the artifact every search delivers
Post the role and the same screener runs on your real applicants — the questions arrive already written, and you read every finalist in full before any fee is due.
The same screener, other roles
- Customer Support VA
- Executive Assistant
- Bookkeeper
- Operations Manager
- Social Media Manager
- Data Entry Specialist
- Content Marketer
- Junior Developer
- Graphic Designer
- Sales Development Rep
- Real Estate VA
- E-commerce VA
- Virtual Assistant
- Video Editor
- Copywriter
- SEO Specialist
- PPC Specialist
- WordPress Developer
- Shopify Developer
- Accountant
- Project Manager
- Lead Generation Specialist
- Web Designer