Sample shortlist · candidates written by us, real screener output
Copywriter
This is what the screening delivers: every candidate scored against the brief, with screening notes, their answers and a graded work sample. These sample candidates were written by us and run through the real screener — the scores and notes are its unedited output.
At a glance
Highest score first. Scores within 2 points are level: when we had the screener read the same two applications again, the gap between them moved by up to 2. A must-have in the brief (below the list) costs 5 points when the application does not show it and 2 when it only partly does.
- Zanele K.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Emmanuel O. mainly on the brief: Emmanuel O. only partly showed "email sequences and landing-page copy for a subscription business".88/100
- Emmanuel O.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Renata B. mainly on the work sample (84 vs 62).83/100
- Renata B.Stops here56/100
2 of 3 clear 70, the score an applicant needs to go on to the written interview. A real shortlist only holds people who clear it and then the interview; the one below it is shown so you can see what the screener turns down.
The brief they were screened against
Role: Copywriter · Band: $1,250–2,200/mo
Must-haves: email sequences and landing-page copy for a subscription business, writes backwards from the action the reader should take, defends word choices with a reason, pushes back on a brief that will underperform
Nice to have: A/B test history with numbers, paid-social ad copy, product descriptions
Scored on 2026-09-23 by the AI screener that grades real applicants: the copywriter rubric, run on claude-sonnet-4-6. Nothing below was edited afterwards — including where it went against a candidate. The rubric and weights are published.
Zanele K. · 1 of 3
SCREEN 88/100How the 88 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%87
Two distinct versions, each opening on a reader moment ('Sunday-night schedule', 'who's actually working Saturday?'), with a clear action and a two-sentence rationale citing Mail Privacy Protection.
- Scenario judgment 25%91
Pushes back on subject line and P.S. with legal grounding, asks five specific pre-write questions, structures the email backwards from one button, and cites a real outcome: 3.4% vs 2.9% cancellations and 7% annual upgrades.
- Experience specificity 20%85
Seven years across named subscription verticals, specific tools listed, and a trial-to-paid lift from 9.8% to 13.1% over two monthly cohorts attributed to a specific rewrite decision.
- Written & spoken English 15%88
Consistently clean and direct; 'a P.S. is a hard place to call conspicuous' shows register control and precision without stiffness.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,900 a month, inside the $1,250–2,200 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- email sequences and landing-page copy for a subscription business — shown
I write the email flows (welcome, trial-to-paid, win-back) and the landing pages they point to
- writes backwards from the action the reader should take — shown
I write backwards from that. If the goal is 'stay, ideally on annual', the one button says 'Keep $29 a month — switch to annual'
- defends word choices with a reason — shown
'swap shifts', not 'workforce management' — because recognising their Sunday night is what earns the second sentence
- pushes back on a brief that will underperform — shown
I'd push back on both, and argue from what happens next rather than from taste
The parts, weighted as above, come to 88.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer — legal awareness, backwards-from-action structure, and a real cancellation/upgrade outcome make it unusually specific.
Concern: Paid-social ad copy is the thinnest area by the candidate's own admission; no ad copy appears in the work sample.
Worth asking: What does their landing-page test process look like end-to-end — brief to Unbounce variant to decision?
Verdict: A well-evidenced subscription copywriter whose scenario and work sample both demonstrate the core method the role requires, with one acknowledged gap in paid social.
Experience
7 years writing for subscription businesses: 3 in-house at a Cape Town language-learning app with mostly US and UK subscribers, then 4 freelance for US subscription brands — a coffee subscription, a meal-kit company and two B2B software tools. I write the email flows (welcome, trial-to-paid, win-back) and the landing pages they point to; paid-social ads are the part I've done least. The result I'd put first: I rewrote a 7-email trial sequence for one of the software tools so every email asked for exactly one action, and trial-to-paid went from 9.8% to 13.1% over the next two monthly cohorts.
Tools
Klaviyo (flows and A/B tests), Customer.io, HubSpot, Unbounce for landing-page tests, Hotjar recordings to see how people actually read a page, GA4, Google Docs with comments for client reviews, Hemingway Editor as a last pass, Figma (commenting only — I'm not a designer)
Scenario answer
Asked: A client wants to send an email announcing a price increase. They've written the subject line: 'Exciting news about your subscription!' and they want to bury the price details in the P.S. Walk through what you'd push back on, what you'd ask before writing, and what the structure of a better email would look like.
I'd push back on both, and argue from what happens next rather than from taste. The subject line promises good news and delivers a higher bill. Some readers will feel tricked, and those are exactly the people who cancel, reply angrily or mark it as spam. The ones who never open it meet the new price on their card statement, which is worse — that's where chargebacks and 'I never agreed to this' tickets come from. The P.S. doesn't make the increase smaller; it makes the company look like it knew the news was bad. I'd also ask whether their lawyer has seen it. I'm not a lawyer, but California's auto-renewal law, for one, now requires a clear and conspicuous notice of a price change, with how to cancel, between 7 and 30 days before it takes effect. A P.S. is a hard place to call conspicuous. What I'd ask before writing: 1. Old price, new price, and when it applies — one date for everyone, or each customer's next renewal? 2. Who's affected? Annual subscribers usually keep their price until renewal and need a different email. 3. Why, honestly. 'Costs went up' is weak on its own; 'we've added X and Y since your price was set' is stronger, if it's true. 4. What can we offer? The old price locked for anyone who switches to annual before the date, or a smaller plan. 5. What should the reader do? I write backwards from that. If the goal is 'stay, ideally on annual', the one button says 'Keep $29 a month — switch to annual', not 'Learn more'. The structure: - Subject: 'Your plan goes from $29 to $34 on April 1' — plain, and it survives a skim. - Preview text: 'What's changing, why, and how to keep your current price.' - First sentence: the change, the amount, the date. - Two or three sentences on why. - The options: annual lock-in as the main button, 'manage or cancel your plan' as a plain link. Hiding the cancel link only moves the problem to support. - P.S.: the deadline for keeping the old price — the one job a P.S. should have here. It goes out about three weeks before the new price, inside that window, with a reminder a week before. I'd judge it on the next month's cancellations against the usual rate, not on opens. On the last price-increase email I wrote, a $5 monthly rise on a coffee subscription, cancellations were 3.4% that month against a usual 2.9%, and 7% of monthly subscribers moved to annual to keep the old price.
Work sample
Asked: Rewrite this subject line and opening sentence: subject 'Checking in about our solution', opening 'I wanted to reach out and introduce our revolutionary platform that helps companies like yours.' Rewrite it for any specific product you know, and explain your changes in two sentences.
PRODUCT: a shift-scheduling app for independent restaurants, $49 a month per location — one of the software tools whose emails I write. READER: an owner or general manager who has never heard of it. THE ACTION I'm writing back from: a reply, not a demo booking, because a stranger will answer a question long before they give a vendor 30 minutes. VERSION A Subject: your Sunday-night schedule Preview: and the week of shift-swap texts that follows it Opening: If you build next week's schedule on Sunday night and spend the rest of the week fixing it by text, that second part is the job we take off your hands. Staff swap shifts in the app, you approve each swap with one tap, and the schedule everyone sees is always the current one — is Sunday night still how you do it? VERSION B, to test against A Subject: who's actually working Saturday? Opening: It's 4pm on a Saturday, and the name on the schedule isn't the person who just walked in. WHY, IN TWO SENTENCES: The original talks about the sender ('I wanted to reach out', 'our revolutionary platform', 'companies like yours'), so both versions open on a job the reader already does and dislikes, in their own words — 'swap shifts', not 'workforce management' — because recognising their Sunday night is what earns the second sentence, and 'revolutionary' earns nothing. 'Checking in' pretends to a relationship that doesn't exist and 'our solution' says nothing, so each subject line names one moment the reader knows, and I'd pick the winner on replies rather than opens, since Apple's Mail Privacy Protection inflates opens.
Availability
Full-time, 12pm–9pm SAST, which gives 5 to 6 hours of overlap with US Eastern. Available in two weeks, once I finish a current project.
Emmanuel O. · 2 of 3
SCREEN 83/100How the 83 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%84
Two concrete variants with real quiz data, dog's name mechanic, and a specific prior A/B result cited to justify the test.
- Scenario judgment 25%88
Identifies deliverability risk with a specific threshold, structures a better email, and admits no prior price-increase email experience.
- Experience specificity 20%82
400 Meta ad variants a year, 38,000-visit split test, 3.2%-to-4.1% subscribe rate lift, named tools and one-client Klaviyo caveat all stated.
- Written & spoken English 15%83
Consistently clear and direct; 'dull on purpose' and 'say the number early and people argue less' show controlled, confident register throughout.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,500 a month, inside the $1,250–2,200 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 3 of 4 shown, 1 partly
- email sequences and landing-page copy for a subscription business — partly shown (−2)
I've written one client's welcome and win-back flows in Klaviyo
- writes backwards from the action the reader should take — shown
THE ONE ACTION: start the first box at the quiz price
- defends word choices with a reason — shown
I replaced every word about the company ('our revolutionary platform', 'companies like yours') with the reader's own quiz answers, because the dog's name and weight prove the email was written for them, and 'revolutionary' proves nothing
- pushes back on a brief that will underperform — shown
I'd push back before writing anything, because this brief will lose them customers they would otherwise keep
The parts, weighted as above, come to 85; must-haves not fully shown cost 2, so 83.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer — deliverability threshold cited, honest structure proposed, and a candid admission of limited price-increase email experience.
Concern: Email depth is thin; Klaviyo work covers one client's flows only, and landing-page experience is heavier than email sequences.
Worth asking: Has the candidate written a full onboarding or promotional email sequence end-to-end, beyond welcome and win-back flows?
Verdict: A strong direct-response candidate with evidenced ad and landing-page results, solid judgment, and a clear email gap that warrants one probing question.
Experience
5 years as a direct-response copywriter at a Manila performance agency whose clients are US subscription brands — supplements, fresh dog food and a skincare box. Most of my work is paid-social ads and the landing pages behind them, around 400 Meta ad variants a year, and I keep a log of every headline test I've run. Best landing-page result: a new headline and first screen for the dog-food subscription moved the subscribe rate from 3.2% to 4.1% across about 38,000 visits in a two-week split test. Email is my thinner side — I've written one client's welcome and win-back flows in Klaviyo.
Tools
Meta Ads Manager (I read the results; the media buyers run the budgets), VWO for landing-page split tests, Unbounce, Shopify page templates, Klaviyo (flows for one client), Google Sheets for my test log, ChatGPT for long first-draft variant lists that I then cut and rewrite
Scenario answer
Asked: A client wants to send an email announcing a price increase. They've written the subject line: 'Exciting news about your subscription!' and they want to bury the price details in the P.S. Walk through what you'd push back on, what you'd ask before writing, and what the structure of a better email would look like.
I'd push back before writing anything, because this brief will lose them customers they would otherwise keep. 'Exciting news about your subscription!' sets up a promise the email breaks. In ads I've seen what a misleading headline does — it wins the click and loses the sale on the next screen. In email the equivalent is an open followed by a cancellation or a spam complaint, and complaints hurt more than this one send: Gmail's sender rules expect complaint rates under 0.3%, and a price rise behind a cheerful subject line is exactly what people report. That damages delivery for every email the brand sends afterwards, including the ones that make money. Price in the P.S.: the people who miss it find out from their card statement. That's where refunds, chargebacks and angry reviews come from, and they cost more than the cancellations an honest email triggers. What I'd ask first: - The numbers: old price, new price, the date, and which customers. - What churn they expect and what they'd accept. If they can live with an extra 1–2% cancelling this month, the honest version is an easy decision. - Is there a real way to soften it — the current price locked for anyone who switches to annual, or grandfathering customers who've been with them over two years? - Their best-performing past emails, so the voice matches. The structure: 1. Subject: 'A price change to your plan on May 1' — dull on purpose. A clear subject gets fewer complaints. 2. First line: what's changing, by how much, from when. 3. Why, in two sentences — what they've added, or what it now costs them. 4. The choice we want them to make, as the only button: lock the current price by going annual. 5. How to change or cancel, as a plain link. 6. A P.S. with the deadline for the lock-in. I'd send two plain subject lines to 20% of the list, then send the winner to the rest two days later, judged on spam complaints and clicks on the lock-in button — not on opens, which Apple's Mail Privacy Protection has made unreliable. To be straight about my experience: I haven't written a price-increase email before. The closest was the landing page and FAQ for a shipping-cost change on the dog-food subscription, and the same rule held there: say the number early and people argue less.
Work sample
Asked: Rewrite this subject line and opening sentence: subject 'Checking in about our solution', opening 'I wanted to reach out and introduce our revolutionary platform that helps companies like yours.' Rewrite it for any specific product you know, and explain your changes in two sentences.
The original reads like a cold B2B email. I've rewritten it for the product I know best, where the equivalent message is the first email after someone takes the feeding quiz and leaves without ordering. PRODUCT: a fresh dog-food subscription — meals portioned by the dog's weight, delivered every two weeks. READER: someone who finished the quiz, gave their email and didn't buy. THE ONE ACTION: start the first box at the quiz price. VERSION A Subject: Biscuit's plan is still saved Preview: 14 days of fresh food, portioned for 31 lb, first box half price Opening: You told us Biscuit is a 31 lb beagle mix who leaves half his kibble in the bowl, so we've already worked out his portions: 14 days of fresh food, measured for his weight, with the first box at half price. VERSION B, the control Subject: Half off Biscuit's first box Opening: Your quiz results are ready — 14 days of fresh food portioned for Biscuit's weight, and the first box is half price. WHY, IN TWO SENTENCES: I replaced every word about the company ('our revolutionary platform', 'companies like yours') with the reader's own quiz answers, because the dog's name and weight prove the email was written for them, and 'revolutionary' proves nothing. I'd run A against B because in my test log the dog's name in the subject beat the discount in the subject on first-box orders in two earlier tests on this brand, by 18% and 6% — close enough that I'd rather measure it again than trust my notes.
Availability
Full-time on US Eastern hours from Manila (night shift). 30 days' notice, as my agency contract requires.
Renata B. · 3 of 3
SCREEN 56/100How the 56 adds up · Competent but generic
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%62
Subject line is functional and benefit-led, but the explanation describes the change rather than defending the strategic word-level choice.
- Scenario judgment 25%66
Identifies the trust problem and asks sensible pre-write questions, but the pushback is gentle and the structural logic stays surface-level.
- Experience specificity 20%44
Names a gym chain, dental clinic, and software company but gives no metrics, no decisions, and no specifics beyond industry labels.
- Written & spoken English 15%72
Clear, correct, and professional throughout; phrasing like I wanted to reach out is flagged and cut, showing register awareness.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,350 a month, inside the $1,250–2,200 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 2 of 4 shown, 1 partly
- email sequences and landing-page copy for a subscription business — partly shown (−2)
email newsletters for clients in different industries, including a gym chain with monthly memberships
- writes backwards from the action the reader should take — not shown (−5)
- defends word choices with a reason — shown
I focused the opening on the benefits for the reader instead of on our company
- pushes back on a brief that will underperform — shown
I would explain to the client that it is better to be transparent with customers
The parts, weighted as above, come to 63; must-haves not fully shown cost 7, so 56.
Screening notes
Strongest: Pushback in the scenario is clear and reasoned; the subject-line swap comes with a stated rationale.
Concern: No numbers anywhere — no open rates, conversion lifts, or sequence lengths — and landing-page copy is absent from the experience.
Worth asking: Can they describe a specific email sequence they wrote end-to-end, including the desired action each email was built around?
Verdict: A competent generalist copywriter with readable English and sound instincts, but thin on subscription-specific depth and measurable results.
Experience
3 years as a copywriter at a marketing agency in Monterrey, writing for local and US clients in English and Spanish. I write website copy, social media posts, blog articles and email newsletters for clients in different industries, including a gym chain with monthly memberships, a dental clinic and a software company. I am a creative and persuasive writer and I adapt my tone to each brand's voice. I am always looking to improve my skills, and I recently completed an online course in email marketing.
Tools
Google Docs, Grammarly, Mailchimp, Canva, WordPress, Meta Business Suite, ChatGPT for brainstorming ideas
Scenario answer
Asked: A client wants to send an email announcing a price increase. They've written the subject line: 'Exciting news about your subscription!' and they want to bury the price details in the P.S. Walk through what you'd push back on, what you'd ask before writing, and what the structure of a better email would look like.
When a client wants to announce a price increase with the subject line 'Exciting news about your subscription!' and put the price details in the P.S., I would first make sure I understand why they want to do it this way. Most likely they are worried that customers will cancel if the price increase is too visible. I would explain to the client that it is better to be transparent with customers, because if they feel the company is hiding something, it can damage their trust in the brand. However, I also understand the client's concern, so I would suggest a balanced approach. Before writing, I would ask what the new price is, when it starts, and what the reasons for the increase are. For the structure, I would start with a friendly introduction thanking the customer for being part of the community. Then I would highlight the new features and improvements they have received, so they can see the value. After that I would mention the new price clearly in the body of the email, not in the P.S. I would end with a positive message and a link to contact support if they have any questions. For the subject line, I would suggest something like 'An update about your subscription' — it is more honest than 'Exciting news' but still friendly and positive.
Work sample
Asked: Rewrite this subject line and opening sentence: subject 'Checking in about our solution', opening 'I wanted to reach out and introduce our revolutionary platform that helps companies like yours.' Rewrite it for any specific product you know, and explain your changes in two sentences.
PRODUCT: a project management app for small teams (monthly subscription) SUBJECT LINE: 'Is your team still managing projects in spreadsheets?' OPENING SENTENCE: 'Hi [Name], I noticed your team has been growing, and I wanted to share a simple tool that helps small teams stay organized and finish projects on time.' ALTERNATIVE SUBJECT LINE: 'A simpler way to manage your team's projects' EXPLANATION: I changed the subject line into a question so it is more engaging and makes the reader curious to open the email. I also removed 'revolutionary' because it sounds too salesy, and I focused the opening on the benefits for the reader instead of on our company.
Availability
Full-time, flexible, can work US hours. Available in two weeks.
This is the artifact every search delivers
Post the role and the same screener runs on your real applicants — the questions arrive already written, and you read every finalist in full before any fee is due.
The same screener, other roles
- Customer Support VA
- Executive Assistant
- Bookkeeper
- Operations Manager
- Social Media Manager
- Data Entry Specialist
- Content Marketer
- Junior Developer
- Graphic Designer
- Sales Development Rep
- Real Estate VA
- E-commerce VA
- Bookkeeping Assistant
- Virtual Assistant
- Video Editor
- SEO Specialist
- PPC Specialist
- WordPress Developer
- Shopify Developer
- Accountant
- Project Manager
- Lead Generation Specialist
- Web Designer