Sample shortlist · candidates written by us, real screener output
Video Editor
This is what the screening delivers: every candidate scored against the brief, with screening notes, their answers and a graded work sample. These sample candidates were written by us and run through the real screener — the scores and notes are its unedited output.
At a glance
Highest score first. Scores within 2 points are level: when we had the screener read the same two applications again, the gap between them moved by up to 2. A must-have in the brief (below the list) costs 5 points when the application does not show it and 2 when it only partly does.
- Camille C.Goes on to the interviewLevel with Mariana L. (86 vs 84 is too close to call); Mariana L. only partly showed "captions and thumbnails" (−2).86/100
- Mariana L.Goes on to the interviewAhead of Bianca T. mainly on the work sample (84 vs 52).84/100
- Bianca T.Stops here53/100
2 of 3 clear 70, the score an applicant needs to go on to the written interview. A real shortlist only holds people who clear it and then the interview; the one below it is shown so you can see what the screener turns down.
The brief they were screened against
Role: Video Editor · Band: $900–1,600/mo
Must-haves: cuts long-form (podcasts, webinars, interviews) into short and mid-length edits, Premiere Pro or DaVinci Resolve, captions and thumbnails, holds a weekly publishing schedule
Nice to have: After Effects motion graphics, reading YouTube retention data, colour and audio clean-up
Scored on 2026-09-23 by the AI screener that grades real applicants: the video-editor rubric, run on claude-sonnet-4-6. Nothing below was edited afterwards — including where it went against a candidate. The rubric and weights are published.
Camille C. · 1 of 3
SCREEN 86/100How the 86 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%84
Specific source length, three named structural decisions with timestamps, retention numbers, and a concrete self-critique of the 3:40 drop.
- Scenario judgment 25%88
Reply drafted before touching the timeline, footage counted honestly, reusable assets itemised, schedule impact flagged same day.
- Experience specificity 20%86
150 episodes, one late, view-duration lift from 3:50 to 6:40, named tools and a specific cold-open change with measured result.
- Written & spoken English 15%82
Consistently clear, correct register throughout; phrase 'you're doing data entry, not accounting' shows confident, client-ready prose.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,300 a month, inside the $900–1,600 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 4 of 4 shown
- cuts long-form (podcasts, webinars, interviews) into short and mid-length edits — shown
one 60–90 minute recording becomes a 25–35 minute YouTube episode, six vertical clips
- Premiere Pro or DaVinci Resolve — shown
Premiere Pro (my main editor — text-based editing for selects, Essential Sound, Auto Reframe for the verticals)
- captions and thumbnails — shown
captions and a thumbnail, delivered by Tuesday noon Eastern
- holds a weekly publishing schedule — shown
delivered by Tuesday noon Eastern — about 150 episodes, one late
The parts, weighted as above, come to 86.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer — honest footage audit, clear asset triage, and same-day schedule communication show real production discipline.
Concern: No shareable portfolio link; work-sample quality cannot be verified visually, only inferred from the written description.
Worth asking: Can they share even one anonymised or older clip on a call to confirm the editing instincts described?
Verdict: A highly specific, well-evidenced application with strong pacing instinct and reliability signals, asking comfortably inside the band.
Experience
6 years editing, the last 3 as the only editor on a US marketing agency's weekly video podcast. Every week one 60–90 minute recording becomes a 25–35 minute YouTube episode, six vertical clips, captions and a thumbnail, delivered by Tuesday noon Eastern — about 150 episodes, one late, during a typhoon power cut I warned them about the night before. The change I'm proudest of: replacing the host's 3-minute welcome with a 20-second cold open from the strongest answer, which took average view duration from 3:50 to 6:40 over the next ten episodes. Before that, 3 years cutting corporate event videos at a Manila post house.
Tools
Premiere Pro (my main editor — text-based editing for selects, Essential Sound, Auto Reframe for the verticals), After Effects (animated captions and lower thirds, saved as .mogrt templates), Photoshop for thumbnails, Audition for problem audio, Frame.io for client review, YouTube Studio (retention reports, and the A/B test for thumbnails), DaVinci Resolve (colour only — I grade there when two cameras don't match, but I'm slow cutting in it)
Scenario answer
Asked: You are halfway through a 45-minute-to-10-minute recut when the client messages: 'We changed the main angle — the hero should be the customer story, not the product demo. Can you rework it?' The final cut is due in two days and you have one day left on this project in your schedule. Walk through exactly what you do — starting with your reply — and what from your current cut you would keep versus restart.
My reply goes out within the hour, before I touch the timeline: 'Understood — customer story as the hero, and Thursday still holds. Two questions so I cut the right thing: is the customer the clinic owner in the recording (from 22:10), or is there a longer interview with her I haven't seen? And should the demo stay as a short proof section, about 90 seconds, or go completely? You'll have a one-page outline of the new structure today and a watchable cut by the end of tomorrow, which leaves the last day for your notes.' Next I count what the footage actually gives me, because that decides what I can promise. In the 45 minutes I have, she is on camera for about 7 minutes, and roughly 4 are usable — the rest is her talking over the host. A 10-minute film carried by 4 minutes of customer would be padding, so if there is no longer interview, the outline recommends 6 minutes instead of 10. It's their call, but they hear it today, not on delivery day. What I keep, because none of it depends on the story order: - the audio clean-up, the colour and the synced camera angles - the demo selects — they stop being the spine and become cutaways under her voice, so when she says 'we stopped double-booking', the viewer sees the calendar doing it - the music bed, lower thirds and end card Captions I regenerate from the final sequence; the style is saved, so that's 20 minutes, not a decision. What I restart: - the spine: the first 60 seconds, the order of the middle, and the ending. A demo-led cut opens on the product; a customer-led cut opens on her problem, in her words. - the demo pacing. It was cut to show every click; as support it only needs the three or four moments she mentions. Tomorrow, the day I have booked: I duplicate the sequence and lock the old one as 'v1 demo-led', so if the angle flips back next week nothing is lost. Then a stringout of every usable customer line from the transcript, her strongest line as the cold open, and the story laid out as problem, turning point, result, with the demo underneath. The honest cost: notes and polish on the last day need about two hours I haven't booked. I tell whoever owns my schedule today and move a batch of Shorts that has a day of slack, rather than finding out at midnight that something has to give.
Work sample
Asked: Paste a link to your best real edit — or, if it's client work you can't share, describe it in enough detail that we can picture it. Either way: how long was the source footage, what was the brief, what were the three specific decisions you made about structure or pacing, and what would you change if you did it again?
No link, sorry: this was for an agency client and the contract doesn't let me show it outside a call, so here is the cut in enough detail to picture it. WORK SAMPLE — a webinar recut for a US accounting-software company SOURCE: a 94-minute webinar — two presenters, slides and 30 minutes of Q&A — recorded in Zoom, with the shared screen and the speaker view as separate files. BRIEF: a 12-minute YouTube version for people who missed it, plus five Shorts to promote it. The client's goal in one line: 'watch to the end and book a demo'. THREE DECISIONS 1. A COLD OPEN FROM MINUTE 71. The first 9 minutes were housekeeping and an agenda slide. The best moment was in the Q&A: asked how long month-end close should take, the presenter said 'if it's more than five days, you're doing data entry, not accounting'. I opened on that line — 12 seconds — and put the title card after it. 2. SLIDES ONLY WHEN THEY CARRY A NUMBER. The middle was 22 minutes of a presenter reading slides. A slide stayed full-screen only if it had a figure the viewer needed to see; for the rest I cut to the presenter, with the slide's one key line as a text overlay. That section went from 22 minutes to 4:30. 3. J-CUTS TO HIDE THE Q&A LAG. Every question had a 3–5 second gap while the presenter read it. I put each question on screen as a text card and started the answer's audio under the card, then removed every pause over half a second — except one. Before admitting the product doesn't handle multi-currency yet, the presenter pauses for 2 seconds. I kept it, because it's where he sounds most honest. ALSO DELIVERED: five Shorts, each a question card plus a one-sentence answer from the Q&A; captions burned into the Shorts and an SRT file on the long version so viewers can switch them off; a thumbnail of the presenter mid-answer with 'MORE THAN 5 DAYS?' as the only text. RESULT: a 12:40 final. Average view duration 5:10, about 41%; the client's earlier uploads, full uncut recordings, averaged around 2:30. WHAT I WOULD CHANGE: the retention graph's steepest drop was at 3:40, from 61% to 52% of viewers in about 20 seconds — a pricing explanation the presenter needed and the viewer didn't. I'd cut it to one on-screen line and put the pricing link in the description. And before the next webinar I'd ask the presenters to answer each question in one sentence first, then explain; it would have saved me most of the J-cut work.
The screener grades what they write about this work: it cannot open a link or watch a video. In a real search the applicant's link opens the work itself, and you look at it before deciding anything. These sample candidates are written, so there is nothing behind a link to show.
Availability
Full-time, 9am–6pm US Eastern from Manila (9pm–6am PHT while the US is on daylight time, 10pm–7am in winter). Two weeks' notice.
Mariana L. · 2 of 3
SCREEN 84/100How the 84 adds up · Top ~10%
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%84
Three named structural decisions with specific timecodes, a retention-data argument, and an honest admission about two unusable shots — detailed and self-critical.
- Scenario judgment 25%88
Leads with a scoping call, names the exact three questions to ask, explains the approval-loop risk, and separates keep/demote/restart with clear reasoning.
- Experience specificity 20%86
8 years, named tools, 96 on-time episodes, specific footage durations, and a retention-data win cited with a concrete viewer-drop number.
- Written & spoken English 15%83
Consistently clear, professional register throughout; 'Thirty seconds of a real number is worth more than two minutes of her saying the product is great' shows confident, precise prose.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $1,550 a month, inside the $900–1,600 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 3 of 4 shown, 1 partly
- cuts long-form (podcasts, webinars, interviews) into short and mid-length edits — shown
cutting customer-story films for US software companies — 8 to 15 minutes each, from 3 to 6 hours of interviews and B-roll
- Premiere Pro or DaVinci Resolve — shown
DaVinci Resolve Studio (edit, grade on the Color page, audio in Fairlight
- captions and thumbnails — partly shown (−2)
I can build a thumbnail from a template, but I'm not a thumbnail designer
- holds a weekly publishing schedule — shown
a weekly 20-minute interview show for a US fintech's YouTube channel plus three Shorts per episode, 96 episodes and none late
The parts, weighted as above, come to 86; must-haves not fully shown cost 2, so 84.
Screening notes
Strongest: Scenario answer — scoping call, three precise questions, approval-loop risk, and a keep/demote/restart breakdown that shows genuine editorial judgment.
Concern: Thumbnails are a stated gap; the candidate describes filling templates, not designing, and flags it as "the weakest part of the job."
Worth asking: Whether the weekly fintech show involved any direct client communication or was mediated by an agency, given the NDA pattern on the work sample.
Verdict: A highly specific, self-aware candidate whose experience maps closely to the role, with one honest gap on thumbnail design near the top of the pay band.
Experience
8 years editing, starting as an assistant editor on documentaries in Bogotá. Then 4 years at a Medellín production company cutting customer-story films for US software companies — 8 to 15 minutes each, from 3 to 6 hours of interviews and B-roll. For the last 2 years, freelance on US Eastern hours: a weekly 20-minute interview show for a US fintech's YouTube channel plus three Shorts per episode, 96 episodes and none late. The film I'm proudest of was cut from 5 hours 20 minutes of footage; it passed 40,000 views in its first year and is the one the client's sales team sends after every first call.
Tools
DaVinci Resolve Studio (edit, grade on the Color page, audio in Fairlight — Voice Isolation for bad rooms), Premiere Pro (fine when a client's project lives there, slower than in Resolve), After Effects (titles and simple lower thirds, not complex motion), Descript for paper edits a client can read, Frame.io, YouTube Studio retention reports, Photoshop — I can build a thumbnail from a template, but I'm not a thumbnail designer; on the weekly show the client's designer made the templates and I filled them in
Scenario answer
Asked: You are halfway through a 45-minute-to-10-minute recut when the client messages: 'We changed the main angle — the hero should be the customer story, not the product demo. Can you rework it?' The final cut is due in two days and you have one day left on this project in your schedule. Walk through exactly what you do — starting with your reply — and what from your current cut you would keep versus restart.
My reply, within the hour: 'Happy to — customer-led films are most of what I cut. Before I change anything, can we take ten minutes on a call today? I want to confirm three things: which customer, whether you have her full interview or only what's in this recording, and whether everyone who approved the demo-led version has seen this change. I'm keeping the deadline as it is; if the answers make that unrealistic, you'll hear it on the call, not later.' The third question is the one I learned to ask. A change of angle mid-project usually comes from someone new joining the conversation, and the expensive outcome isn't re-cutting once — it's re-cutting twice because the original approver pulls it back after seeing the new version. I'd rather find that out before I spend the day. After the call I send a four-line summary: the new hero, what happens to the demo, the running time, the deadline. That's what I cut to, and what we both point to if it changes again. Then I check what the footage really supports. A customer story needs three things from the customer herself: the problem in her words, the moment it changed, and a result she can put a number on. Recordings like this one usually have the first two and not the third, because nobody asked her. If it's missing, I say so and ask whether someone can record her answering one question on her phone. Thirty seconds of a real number is worth more than two minutes of her saying the product is great. Keep versus restart: - Keep: the grade, the audio work, the synced angles, the lower-third design and the caption styling. None of it depends on the order. - Keep, but demote: the product demo. It becomes proof inside her story — it appears when she describes what changed, and never for longer than she's talking about it. - Restart: the structure. I don't rearrange the demo-led timeline; I build a new one from her selects and leave the old one untouched. A customer film and a product film have different spines, and patching one into the other shows. Timing: tomorrow, my one booked day, goes on the new structure and a rough cut by 4pm Eastern. I work the same hours as the client, so notes come back that afternoon, and the polish fits into the morning of the deadline day — the day I have, plus a few hours of buffer I keep on every project for exactly this.
Work sample
Asked: Paste a link to your best real edit — or, if it's client work you can't share, describe it in enough detail that we can picture it. Either way: how long was the source footage, what was the brief, what were the three specific decisions you made about structure or pacing, and what would you change if you did it again?
The film is live on the client's site, but the agency I cut it for doesn't let editors list its clients publicly. I'm happy to screen-share it on a call; here it is in detail. WORK SAMPLE — a customer-story film for a US payroll software company SOURCE: 5 hours 20 minutes — a 2-hour interview with the customer (a bakery owner in Ohio with 14 employees), a 1-hour interview with her operations manager, and 2 hours 20 minutes of B-roll shot in one day. Two cameras on the interviews; the B-roll camera had a different white balance and was underexposed in the kitchen. BRIEF: a 10-minute film for the website and YouTube, plus a 60-second cut for paid social. The one instruction: 'make people feel what a payroll mistake costs a small business'. THREE DECISIONS 1. SHE INTRODUCES HERSELF AT 1:40, NOT AT 0:00. The interview opened with her name, the bakery and how long she'd had it. I opened instead on her worst day: two bakers found their pay short on a Friday, and one of them quit. Her introduction comes once the viewer already cares, as a lower third over her unlocking the shop at 4am. 2. NO INTERVIEWER IN THE FILM. I removed every question and built the story only from answers where she restated the question herself — 'the reason we switched was…'. That took most of a day in the transcript, but it plays as her story rather than an interview about software, which is what the brief was really asking for. 3. THE PRODUCT APPEARS ONCE, LATE. The client wanted the dashboard in the first minute. I showed it once, for 20 seconds, at 6:10, when she describes the first payroll that ran on time. Before that point a viewer has no reason to care what the screen looks like, and their two earlier customer films both lost a third of viewers at the first screen recording, which is the number that won the argument. FOOTAGE, HONESTLY: two of the kitchen shots were too dark to save even after matching them in Resolve, so I used two photos from the bakery's own Instagram, with permission and a slow push-in, and told the client why before they asked. RESULT: a 10:30 film, the 60-second cut, and chapters in the YouTube description so the sales team can link to a specific moment. WHAT I WOULD CHANGE: the product first appears at 6:10. That's right for the film, but the sales team skips straight to it on calls, so I'd put a 10-second glimpse of it in the first minute. I'd also get help with the thumbnail — I built it from the client's template, and it was the weakest part of the job.
The screener grades what they write about this work: it cannot open a link or watch a video. In a real search the applicant's link opens the work itself, and you look at it before deciding anything. These sample candidates are written, so there is nothing behind a link to show.
Availability
Full-time on US Eastern hours from Medellín: no time difference in the US winter, and in summer I start at 8am so it's still 9–6 Eastern. Three weeks' notice.
Bianca T. · 3 of 3
SCREEN 53/100How the 53 adds up · Thin
A bar is as long as its part's weight; the filled share is the score out of 100.
- Graded work sample 35%52
Describes podcast clip work with some pacing detail but no link, no measurable outcome, and decisions stay generic.
- Scenario judgment 25%48
Stays positive and re-watches footage but never weighs the time tradeoff or flags a deadline risk to the client.
- Experience specificity 20%55
Eight months of weekly podcast editing and TikTok/Reels work named, but no client names, view counts, or output numbers.
- Written & spoken English 15%72
Clear, correct sentences throughout; register is polite and professional, though phrases like 'keep the client happy' are informal.
- Salary-band fit 5%100
Asks $950 a month, inside the $900–1,600 band.
Must-haves in the brief: 2 of 4 shown, 2 partly
- cuts long-form (podcasts, webinars, interviews) into short and mid-length edits — shown
the client wanted 4 short clips for TikTok and Instagram Reels to promote the full episode on YouTube
- Premiere Pro or DaVinci Resolve — partly shown (−2)
Premiere Pro (intermediate, I use it for longer videos)
- captions and thumbnails — shown
I added bold captions in yellow and white with some emojis
- holds a weekly publishing schedule — partly shown (−2)
The parts, weighted as above, come to 57; must-haves not fully shown cost 4, so 53.
Screening notes
Strongest: Consistent weekly podcast editing for 8 months shows real repeatable-schedule experience.
Concern: Main editing tool is CapCut; Premiere Pro is self-rated only intermediate, and DaVinci Resolve is absent.
Worth asking: Can they share the actual podcast clips? What does their Premiere Pro workflow look like on a longer cut?
Verdict: A capable short-form editor with relevant podcast experience, but tool depth and scenario judgement fall short of the role's demands.
Experience
3 years as a freelance video editor. I edit short-form videos for Reels and TikTok for small businesses and content creators, and for the last 8 months I have also edited a weekly podcast for a Filipino business coach, cutting each episode into short clips. I am fast and creative, and I always meet my deadlines. I am comfortable with trending editing styles and I know how to make videos engaging for social media.
Tools
CapCut (desktop and mobile — my main editor), Premiere Pro (intermediate, I use it for longer videos), Canva for thumbnails, Photoshop (basic), Google Drive
Scenario answer
Asked: You are halfway through a 45-minute-to-10-minute recut when the client messages: 'We changed the main angle — the hero should be the customer story, not the product demo. Can you rework it?' The final cut is due in two days and you have one day left on this project in your schedule. Walk through exactly what you do — starting with your reply — and what from your current cut you would keep versus restart.
When the client changes the main angle halfway through the project, I would reply right away to confirm that I got the message and that I will rework the video so the customer story is the main focus. I would stay positive, because changes are normal in video editing and it is important to keep the client happy. Then I would watch the footage again, find all the parts where the customer is talking, and choose the best moments. I would keep the intro, the music and the ending from my current cut, and restart the middle part so it follows the customer's story from beginning to end. Some of the product demo can still be used as B-roll while the customer is talking. Since I only have one day left in my schedule, I would work extra hours to make sure the new version is finished on time, and send it to the client for feedback before the deadline. If they have revisions, I will do them quickly. I believe good communication and flexibility are very important when a client changes direction, and I always make sure the client is satisfied with the final video.
Work sample
Asked: Paste a link to your best real edit — or, if it's client work you can't share, describe it in enough detail that we can picture it. Either way: how long was the source footage, what was the brief, what were the three specific decisions you made about structure or pacing, and what would you change if you did it again?
WORK SAMPLE — short clips from a business podcast SOURCE FOOTAGE: one podcast episode, about 1 hour, recorded with two cameras. BRIEF: the client wanted 4 short clips for TikTok and Instagram Reels to promote the full episode on YouTube. THREE DECISIONS 1. I chose the most interesting parts of the episode, where the guest shares practical tips, because those moments give value to the viewer and make them want to watch the full episode. 2. I used fast pacing with jump cuts to remove the pauses and filler words, so the clips feel energetic and keep the viewer watching until the end. 3. I added bold captions in yellow and white with some emojis, and zoom-ins on important words, because captions help people follow along without sound and it matches the trending style. WHAT I WOULD CHANGE: I would make the hook in the first 3 seconds stronger, because some of the clips started a bit slow. I would also try adding sound effects to make them more engaging.
The screener grades what they write about this work: it cannot open a link or watch a video. In a real search the applicant's link opens the work itself, and you look at it before deciding anything. These sample candidates are written, so there is nothing behind a link to show.
Availability
Full-time, night shift PHT to cover US hours. Available immediately.
This is the artifact every search delivers
Post the role and the same screener runs on your real applicants — the questions arrive already written, and you read every finalist in full before any fee is due.
The same screener, other roles
- Customer Support VA
- Executive Assistant
- Bookkeeper
- Operations Manager
- Social Media Manager
- Data Entry Specialist
- Content Marketer
- Junior Developer
- Graphic Designer
- Sales Development Rep
- Real Estate VA
- E-commerce VA
- Bookkeeping Assistant
- Virtual Assistant
- Copywriter
- SEO Specialist
- PPC Specialist
- WordPress Developer
- Shopify Developer
- Accountant
- Project Manager
- Lead Generation Specialist
- Web Designer